Entry # Name Elimination # Eliminated by # of eliminations 1 Levi Carmina 5 Damien James Reiker 3 2 Ted Lavigne 1 Levi Carmina 0 3 Avery Amazing 2 Levi Carmina 0 4 Diamond Goro 9 Thor 1 5 Damon Reid 7 Diamond Goro 0 6 Sue 6 Big Crazy 1 7 Damien James Reiker 21 The Mexicutioner 2 8 Ivan Breznev 3 Levi Carmina 0 9 Manslaughter 20 Dick Shrader 3 10 Jeb Hickory 11 CPL Punishment 0 11 Big Crazy 10 Thor 1 12 Chase Alexander 22 The Mexicutioner 0 13 Mayhem 4 Manslaughter 1 14 CPL Punishment 19 Manslaughter 1 15 Oden 26 Dick Shrader 4 16 Rowdy Richie 18 Oden 2 17 Thor 13 Rowdy Richie 1 18 Donald Dodge Dodson 8 Manslaughter 0 19 Loki 12 Rowdy Richie 0 20 Italian Roc 14 Oden 0 21 BeeHeMoth 15 Oden 0 22 Austin Lee 25 Dick Shrader 0 23 Dick Shrader 27 Axel Kaiser 3 24 Tremier Vampyre 24 Oden 1 25 Rage Hammer 16 Damien James Reiker 0 26 The Mexicutioner 23 Axel Kaiser 2 27 Axel Kaiser Winner Winner 2 28 Reed Grimm 17 Tremier Vampyre